Boundaries, Blackmail, And Double Binds: A Pattern Observed In Malpractice Consultation.
Abstract
A scenario common to several boundary violation/sexual misconduct cases is reviewed and discussed. Common features include an articulate patient whose high functionality concealed more primitive dynamics that arose in the therapy; boundary problems, often on an “attempted rescue” basis; and eventual litigation in some form. The patient's high functioning appeared to cause the therapists to underestimate the severity of the patients' disturbances. Drawing on forensic experience, the author analyses the cases and suggests risk management approaches.
In malpractice prevention and risk management consultation, boundary questions are a very common concern among consultees. Such questions account for a considerable portion of legal and ethics-related difficulties for clinicians. The subject has been extensively discussed in the professional literature (see, for example, Refs. 1–10).
Over time, a particular pattern has emerged that seems to pose repeated problems and create familiar pitfalls for the therapists involved. This review lays out the pattern and indicates...